Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Scopus Web of Science® Altmetric
Type: Journal article
Title: Misconceptions about analyses of Australian seaweed collections
Author: Wernberg, T.
Russell, B.
Bradshaw, C.
Gurgel, C.
Thomsen, M.
Poloczanska, E.
Connell, S.
Citation: Phycologia, 2014; 53(3):215-220
Publisher: International Phycological Society
Issue Date: 2014
ISSN: 0031-8884
Statement of
Thomas Wernberg, Bayden D. Russell, Corey J.A. Bradshaw, C. Frederico D. Gurgel, Mads S. Thomsen, Elvira Poloczanska and Sean D. Connell
Abstract: One of the greatest impediments to detecting changes in species distributions in response to ocean warming is the lack of baseline data. In a recent article, we compared old (1940–1959) and new (1990–2009) herbarium records of Australian seaweeds and found a net southward shift in the latitude of northernmost collections of temperate species, implying a flora-wide poleward retreat over the past five decades. Huisman & Millar (2013) criticised our methods, contending that a comparison of herbarium records from different time periods cannot be used to infer changes in species distributions without field-based validation. However, our analysis compared the median position of extreme records of random species from random locations rather than focusing on particular species and their possible loss from specific sites. Hence, ground-truthing ‘extinctions' are of limited value to the interpretation of our analysis. Moreover, subtidal ground-truthing over biogeographic scales is not logistically possible and even runs counter to entire disciplines (e.g. palaeontology, extinction biology and biogeography) that assess hypotheses of extinction and shifting distributions. Huisman & Millar also questioned the direction of biases in the data set. We show here that patterns of collection effort should have produced an apparent shift northward in the absence of a true shift southward. Even if herbaria were not designed for the purpose of detecting species' range changes, we contend that such collections can contain useful information on the distribution of species across space and time.
Keywords: Climate change; Collection bias; Global warming; Herbarium data; Macroalgae; Range shift
Rights: © 2014 International Phycological Society
RMID: 0030000015
DOI: 10.2216/13-197.1
Appears in Collections:Ecology, Evolution and Landscape Science publications

Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.